Poll: RvR System Proposal

[Razid1987]

Maybe, I support this proposal with a change (please explain)

I suppose this system, but with 2 out of 3 zones open. Or even all 3 zones open, if the population is there for it. If the population gets big enough, having all players in one RvR-lake might also be a problem for the server.

Also, please don't include SC win points. That was a pain (Look at Tesq's post below).

[Tesq]

-sc contribution was a bad designed choice; scenary are not part of the open rvr, if one faction would like to avoid fight, he will send his best premades in sc and problbly block the lock for the entire other faction. And there are no conutermisure to this exept send 1 other better premade and kill them, then at that point they can simply stop play by craft, pve and totaly stop the whole thing.
It would be better add a dominion timer lock after 20-30 min so this would encourage small skirm to steal flags.


-The scaling in skirmish VP is what i asked for and i support this idea, the outnumbered faction should gain or have less vp for lock
check

-dont like the 1 zone open but the whole thing can be try
but until now it didn't shine

-either dont like the x1-x2-"x6" rewards, give more rewards encourage only a zerg, give x3 to defendere is pointless when they opposite faction get x6 for a lock.
As aza said any solution that do not fix the zerg problem should not take in consideration and the whole things do not solve this problem.

-of course ppl out of rvr zone should not be taken in account O.o ppl that do not move in rvr zone should get un-log by default after 2 min, there are no resource carrier so ppl do not have interest in avoid the log out system.
check

N.B.with t3 otw we need ppl that unlog near BO/keep to get port/ log ar wc; this is important as ppl could exploit this and pass 2 door and kill keep lord. (this have nothing to do with rvr changes but is something needed anyway).

[Razid1987]

-sc contribution was a bad designed choice; scenary are not part of the open rvr, if one faction would like to avoid fight, he will send his best premades in sc and problbly block the lock for the entire other faction. And there are no conutermisure to this exept send 1 other better premade and kill them, then at that point they can simply stop play by craft, pve and totaly stop the whole thing.
It would be better add a dominion timer lock after 20-30 min so this would encourage small skirm to steal flags.

But that's "PvE" and the devs don't like that. Hence why we don't have a multi-zone system atm. Although I do agree with you on the scenarios. I remember it was a pain.

As aza said any solution that do not fix the zerg problem should not take in consideration and the whole things do not solve this problem.

I'm afraid there is only one solution. Thought pretty carefully about it, and I'm unable to find another one at least.

-of course ppl out of rvr zone should not be taken in account O.o ppl that do not move in rvr zone should get un-log by default after 2 min, there are no resource carrier so ppl do not have interest in avoid the log out system.check

I agree, but 2 mins is a little harsh though. Maybe 5 mins instead?

[Koradrell]

In general, I love the Idea, but I would propose some tweaks:
- Remove rewards for AFKrs and leechers. Just don't reward those without RvR status, and do not give RvR status if one is in the warcamp.
- Enforce splitting more the people thorugh BO scaling. I love the general scaling Idea, but I would also scale the timers of the BOs, so the larger the amount of people, the smaller the time a BO is locked, so enforce the zerg to split to hold them.

[Sulorie]

As aza said any solution that do not fix the zerg problem should not take in consideration and the whole things do not solve this problem.

I'm afraid there is only one solution. Thought pretty carefully about it, and I'm unable to find another one at least.

When this is the one I think about, then it is a good idea.

[Sulorie]

In general, I love the Idea, but I would propose some tweaks:
- Remove rewards for AFKrs and leechers. Just don't reward those without RvR status, and do not give RvR status if one is in the warcamp.
- Enforce splitting more the people thorugh BO scaling. I love the general scaling Idea, but I would also scale the timers of the BOs, so the larger the amount of people, the smaller the time a BO is locked, so enforce the zerg to split to hold them.

The first suggestion does not help as people would wait in front of wc with several groups and queue for sc. They are not afk, get rewards and do nothing to help their realm for rvr.

The second one is good. Already using parts of it in my WiP rvr system.

[Razid1987]

As aza said any solution that do not fix the zerg problem should not take in consideration and the whole things do not solve this problem.

I'm afraid there is only one solution. Thought pretty carefully about it, and I'm unable to find another one at least.

When this is the one I think about, then it is a good idea.

Think of a better one then, wiseguy.

[Sulorie]

When this is the one I think about, then it is a good idea.

Think of a better one then, wiseguy.

Then there are two ideas and yours must be horrible.

[Razid1987]

When this is the one I think about, then it is a good idea.

Think of a better one then, wiseguy.

Then there are two ideas and yours must be horrible.

Go away, troll

[Sulorie]

You are not as smart as you think. To know it better is no trolling. Same with recognizing flaws in suggestions.