Return of Reckoning

In this LOTD I checked and indeed killing Mobs registers kill damage. This wouldn't necessarily invalidate the entirety of both analyses, but it makes it exceptionally harder to filter that data out of the overall kill damage. Especially in LOTD if just one side has people farming scales or just fig...

For this specific city I'd say it's way better than it could be if kill damage to NPCs counts. Order: -10 or so mobs of ~5k HP to get to the first BO. - No cannon kills - No stage 2 Hero kills - No stage 3 Leader kill Destro: -No stage 2 Hero kills - Karl Franz kill Will try to find out if the kill ...

Just thought of something. Ingame scoreboard counts dmg done to NPCs as "Kill Dmg", is the website doing so too? Any players that were in that City remember how it went? Did Order cap anything? Who killed the Lords in phases 2 and 3? If true then it could pretty much invalidate both analy...

New analysis of a quite equal City fight on 13/5/24 is also ready: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1tqj2-eT3BSD1zk5XoIconTNrrMi4IuwwPaXsTLHEBw0/edit?usp=sharing You will see how despite Order losing, they managed to sustain themselves much better than Destro did, achieving a (destro to order) Rec...

I don't know how much time spend OP to analyze 1 lotd, but it would be interesting to look more closely at least at last 5-10 lotd and compare it. It took around 10 h to type out the entire analysis, but I'd say after having the methodology already established it would take around 3-4h per LOTD now...

I'll give my opinions on some of your assumptions, cuz i believe two are wrong. Balanced between organizations: Order was better. FMJ, Bene and Black Horror all brought the same amount of players, but FMJ had 2.5 to 3x as many kills as the other two. While on Order, FMJ and Retri had the same amoun...

- The difference in heals, similar to tanks, should again be less than it seems. Doing the same trick as before we get 72 Destro healers vs 55 healers for Order. However in this case, I'd say Order had way more dps healers in the form of AMs roaming in ranged comps. Taking a closer look to the gear...

Akalukz wrote: ↑Thu May 16, 2024 5:18 pm Not sure if this is the one that you analyzed or not, but thought it was rather telling. https://killboard.returnofreckoning.com ... b3b/damage

That is the LOTD I analyzed, yes.

In total 48 tanks, 80 dps and 79 healers for Destro In total 42 tanks, 90 dps and 55 healers for Order I wouldn't be able to put the amount of time and thought into a post like you have. But I zeroed in right away on the number of healers, and slight edge in tanks destroy had and would have guessed...

Hi, I applaud you for the detailed analysis. The only thing that i want to mention is that your assumptions of how the "REALM" is designed and works is something you should review to make sure it does not screw your conclusion. You found some unique order skills that are not cloned to des...