Page 4 of 4

Re: Bane shield ICD not working

Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2025 6:32 pm
by Florian90210
No fun allowed, I bet it will get nerfed.
Leveled magus recently and it's so stupidly easy to spam 5 aoe attacks and farm RP. Don't even need group for this, only solo. While choppa needs both tank and healer to do any damage.

Re: Bane shield ICD not working

Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2025 6:37 pm
by Ceithin
ScreenFofoBan wrote: Wed Mar 19, 2025 6:29 pm
Ceithin wrote: Wed Mar 19, 2025 6:28 pm
ScreenFofoBan wrote: Wed Mar 19, 2025 6:13 pm WL need nerf we all know that but dont act like you dont know what a good fight look like, it certainly not look like 1 button stacked chosen either
What you are trying to say is, "a good fight is 2/2/2 v 2/2/2, dont do otherwise cause i say so", where is the fun ?
We tried something atypic, it worked, we had FUN.
1 button gameplay shouldnt be promoted in any way, binary comp should always be bader than a diversified one or it end up in class stacking, and its already happening with WL on order side, and that kind of comp with chosen are promoting this too, if u dont want to end up with 3 class in a wb on each side at least dont practice it, its everyone responsability, specially organised guild like TUP
Why only saying 1 guild name when there are other organised guilds ? TUP is not allowed to have fun ? TUP is not allowed to try new things to counter the WL meta ? TUP must play a 2/2/2 and judge others like you do ?

Re: Bane shield ICD not working

Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2025 6:42 pm
by Illuminati
The ICD is there, you're just getting hit by multiple Chosens at the same time.

If the Devs tweak Baneshield so a player can only feel the affect from one, then,

-Nerf Bitterstone's guild coordinated Engi attacks
-Nerf the 10x WL spin-2-win AOE attacks I get hit with by multiple WLs
-Nerf the dots from all the AMs that stack when I run to any rvr fight or take a piss by a tree
-or the SW AoE spread....etc. etc.

You should die to 24x Chosens... just like I die to multiple AMs, Engi's, BWs, etc.

Re: Bane shield ICD not working

Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2025 6:43 pm
by Sinisterror
Are people upset because they spam aoe without checking buffs and kill themselves instead of stopping aoe spam? lol

Re: Bane shield ICD not working

Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2025 6:50 pm
by ScreenFofoBan
Ceithin wrote: Wed Mar 19, 2025 6:37 pm
ScreenFofoBan wrote: Wed Mar 19, 2025 6:29 pm
Ceithin wrote: Wed Mar 19, 2025 6:28 pm
What you are trying to say is, "a good fight is 2/2/2 v 2/2/2, dont do otherwise cause i say so", where is the fun ?
We tried something atypic, it worked, we had FUN.
1 button gameplay shouldnt be promoted in any way, binary comp should always be bader than a diversified one or it end up in class stacking, and its already happening with WL on order side, and that kind of comp with chosen are promoting this too, if u dont want to end up with 3 class in a wb on each side at least dont practice it, its everyone responsability, specially organised guild like TUP
Why only saying 1 guild name when there are other organised guilds ? TUP is not allowed to have fun ? TUP is not allowed to try new things to counter the WL meta ? TUP must play a 2/2/2 and judge others like you do ?

Tbh its because i didnt expect this from them, they never needed to play this way for rolling on everyone contrary to certain wb lead who would do nothing without stackin WL but u are right and i pretty sure they the first to know they are stacking WL like there is no tomorow and its hurt bad other class who would want to join and do things too, it would be sad if 80% of melee dps are WL just like it would be sad if 80% of tank were chosen, at least its my point of view on this, i like the diversity of class in this game and think we shouldnt promote binary comp.

Re: Bane shield ICD not working

Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2025 6:55 pm
by emiliorv
Illuminati wrote: Wed Mar 19, 2025 6:42 pm The ICD is there, you're just getting hit by multiple Chosens at the same time.

If the Devs tweak Baneshield so a player can only feel the affect from one, then,

-Nerf Bitterstone's guild coordinated Engi attacks
-Nerf the 10x WL spin-2-win AOE attacks I get hit with by multiple WLs
-Nerf the dots from all the AMs that stack when I run to any rvr fight or take a piss by a tree
-or the SW AoE spread....etc. etc.

You should die to 24x Chosens... just like I die to multiple AMs, Engi's, BWs, etc.
Bane shield is not an attack, its an enchantment and should not stack x6, ignoring the basic stacking rules.

Re: Bane shield ICD not working

Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2025 7:09 pm
by GGen
its not a stack its multiples instances you ignorant ****. ever had multiples hots on you ? those are enchantments

Re: Bane shield ICD not working

Posted: Wed Mar 19, 2025 7:13 pm
by Rydiak
This thread is devolving into name calling.

The original post has been discussed, a bug report has been submitted, and it is up to the devs to decide if multiple Chosens can place a Bane Shield on one target at a time.