Return of Reckoning

On live you didnt got surrender vote and to avoid quitter debuff need to stay and fight for the whole 15 mins. And back then you had guards on all maps and safe way back so rdps and healers could get some safety while tanks and mdps could try to take a kill or so. Beside even if that was hard you always had opportunities to punt enemy into your guards that insta kill but also give that juicy renown to your team.
Yes that are not the best comeback mechanics but are much better than the meat grinder that we had now.

So matchmaking wont solve anything. The superior premade will crush and farm the weaker one that could not put a fight and just disband and the noone in rhe queue

Unified currency made scenario gear/weapons available through war crests. The new sets/weapons made the scenario gear redundant / not needed.

The fact there are entire blob guilds running around rr80+ BiS with chars that have done <100 sc's (mostly premade only for guild coins) is wild. I must be around the 20k mark with all chars combined.

Ultimately, sc's need to reward more warcrests to incentivize people to queue over blobbing and some mechanic to prevent premade farming pugs. And scenario wins tied to map/campaign completion like live.

They don't need to reintroduce the 75% scroll to fix it, just make sc's worth 70-80% less xp and jack the rewards up. Then people will queue and play a lot more before getting to t4 (to be farmed) while entering t4 with a chance to be in full vanq -- the min needed gear for most classes to be competitive.

Nice summary.
If I may add an anecdote:
On my latest journey to rr80 i only played around 10 scenarios in T2+.

I remember how I got in a serpents passage scenario 5v6.
We got stomped and I tried to kite back to my camp only to be met with barriers blocking my return. I then tried to swim away hoping I could use my knockbacks and slows only to be exploded by 'my own stupidty'.
I never queued another sc solo. I don't think a system that ensures I have no way to escape death when my team already got their heads bashed in is encouraging me to play scenarios.

Nameless wrote: Tue Aug 19, 2025 7:18 pm On live you didnt got surrender vote and to avoid quitter debuff need to stay and fight for the whole 15 mins. And back then you had guards on all maps and safe way back so rdps and healers could get some safety while tanks and mdps could try to take a kill or so. Beside even if that was hard you always had opportunities to punt enemy into your guards that insta kill but also give that juicy renown to your team.
Yes that are not the best comeback mechanics but are much better than the meat grinder that we had now.

So matchmaking wont solve anything. The superior premade will crush and farm the weaker one that could not put a fight and just disband and the noone in rhe queue

On live you did not have such an aggressive afk timer and you could just sit out in the map somewhere and chill without fear of getting afk'd or you could just try and fight, die and stay dead and afk for the rest of the sc.

Endari wrote: Tue Aug 19, 2025 10:50 pm

Nameless wrote: Tue Aug 19, 2025 7:18 pm On live you didnt got surrender vote and to avoid quitter debuff need to stay and fight for the whole 15 mins. And back then you had guards on all maps and safe way back so rdps and healers could get some safety while tanks and mdps could try to take a kill or so. Beside even if that was hard you always had opportunities to punt enemy into your guards that insta kill but also give that juicy renown to your team.
Yes that are not the best comeback mechanics but are much better than the meat grinder that we had now.

So matchmaking wont solve anything. The superior premade will crush and farm the weaker one that could not put a fight and just disband and the noone in rhe queue

On live you did not have such an aggressive afk timer and you could just sit out in the map somewhere and chill without fear of getting afk'd or you could just try and fight, die and stay dead and afk for the rest of the sc.

Still ppl fought cos you got save spot for backlines which give some chance for frontline to do something. And even if u cant, guards kills were tons of renown.
Yea, you could chill somewhere on the map (which is possible on ror also, there are some ways that even make it easier than on war) but you got initiative to fight. On ror you got initiative to be farmed without any chance to learn whatsoever

Nameless wrote: Tue Aug 19, 2025 11:10 pm
Still ppl fought cos you got save spot for backlines which give some chance for frontline to do something. And even if u cant, guards kills were tons of renown.
Yea, you could chill somewhere on the map (which is possible on ror also, there are some ways that even make it easier than on war) but you got initiative to fight. On ror you got initiative to be farmed without any chance to learn whatsoever

You are not completely wrong but don't just view live under your nostalgia glasses. People quit scs on live, a lot of people, it was a major problem. Especially since weapons were tied to sc currency, afk'ers were a real menace and since they would stay in the sc afk there was no chance of a real fight when half of your team was afk and the sc would last its entire length because the other side was farming the few that were playing. Surrender is a huge boon for RoR as it gets you out of an sc where you will get nothing but wasted time.

Instead of 1 pug scenario and the rest are premades it should be the opposite have 1 premade sc and the rest pug scs.
And also people say just join the pug sc but it almost never pops since people have stopped doing scs to much getting farmed by premades.

The sc is not playable at all now. snb tank play like 2h tank 2h tank play like dps. mdps play like rdps. rdps play like mdps(pug vs pug)，A long time ago everyone did their jobs in sc

Great summary by the OP of the current situation of SCs. I agree that SC's at the moment are one of the biggest things that most of us enjoy but end up hating cause of the constant problems everyone has mentioned in this thread. It's talked about a lot I'm sure on both sides and frustration around them as new players, solo que's and premade groups vs pugs.

One idea came to my mind is to implement something like what is used for the Saga event with grudge buffs. Either based on the match winning/loss streaks or just included for inside the current scenario. I think something like this would help smooth things out, like a band-aid till a better solution can be found.

The players who win consistent matches, get rewarded with a stacking renown buff which would still let premade have their need to continue matchmaking instead of doing ranked but the players who have losing streaks get stacking stat buffs. The incentive to keep playing the match to the end/keep que's active would I think help since it would help at least make the losing side feel like "I can't wait to get payback now against those same people who kicked our ass x times" and the winning side at least can have a challenge if the other team is under geared, pugs, new players or whatever.

scenario wins tied to map/campaign completion like live

That was ultra toxic, on a levels nowhere near solo prankeds even. any newcomer/newbie ocassionally joining "wrong" SC has been flamed like hell
I, personally, all in for that tbf, I did love e.g. solo prankeds toxicity, it created lots of memes, stories, clips and was pretty healthy for some part of community (while for the other part it has been totally unacceptable).
But by doing what you suggest we will open up a salt mine that big, that Malcham cave would look like a tiny hole in a garden in comparison. Just FYI

Also, another thing to comment in this thread - i believe we as community already gathered up lots of solid ideas for SCs rework, Only did create a manifest with this thread nailing the issue most preciosly so next step would be to refine and summarize all ideas. Barriers, guards, transparency who is in q, saga buff, MM (dont think they need help or ideas here tho, they know better how to construct it tbf), reducing XP gains + increasing RR gains (drastically required in midtier, its plain impossible to do SCs there you outlevel RR just way too fast while gains are totally the same as in T4), bring back old 6v6 system (havent been raised in this thread, but community point on it is loud&clear - not asked, not needed).

Also most important part that nobody mentioned here was refined and evaluated thru millions of whine threads in a category of "scary premades mess up my solo sc&stomps are not fun" thesis - there should be some comeback mechanics for SCs by design (either by map or by "system"). And no, current "tank m4 for 10 seconds when you leave WC" is not it, current thingy is worthless and lame desinged, dirty smelly contagious bandaid ensuring that something will be infected and cut off very soon. Nobody ever since then came up with some nice ideas but however its imo clear that this is a hugest issue and main general direction of changes for revamping SCs. Because most unfun part that any part (elitists, carebears, newcomers whoever) of community shares is that current SC system is "Stomp or be Stomped".

P.S. people do claim that MM wont help but it, along with transperacy for a q (alike rankeds), are the easiest and long overdue steps that RoR team can easily make. it should be a step 1 im convinced. totally agree with rest of folks that barriers and guards should be reverted ASAP. guards should award renown, barriers have to be gone along with stupid antiAFK (="go get farmed bro") mechanics (afterwards i believe it would be logical to look on surrender timers more closely and decide if it needs to be adjusted).