salazarn wrote: ↑Sat Mar 30, 2024 2:11 pm
[Biased rant about how order bad, destro too op etc.]
ahh yes the point of view sits on the point of sitting, roll a destro char, farm it and try to solo roam on destro with "superior classes" i bet in 30 days you will come back cry about how order is op in solo roam. The same goes for all of the soloq experience. And this forum post is just classical "i want attention" post type beat.
Anyways, SH/SW debate, can't talk much personally i would say SW is stronger based on what rSH players i know say. Not to say that SW's are old WH players that now group with 4-6 rSW spamming everyone they see to death.
Magus/engiee debate, the issue with your view is that magus is mostly otp class for people who enjoy pain too much, granted now it starts getting traction but we still have only 45 maguses that are rr80 (over 2x less than avarage) Both are not mirrors and both are for different playstyles, you dont see magus in wb play but you see engiee. engiee also works for solo roam the same way magus works and deftard engiee still hards quite hard. It's just that all weak magus players have stopped playing way before they reached anywhere close to bis.
WE/WH - mostly issue with BAL not being spirit damage, make it spirit and both classes are quite even and both would run deftard. The issue is that no matter what you do with that class except removing it you gonna have people complaining, nerf damage too much -> welcome deftard regen, nerf survivability -> glasscannon builds, nerf both -> the class players will cry
Choppa/SL - The difference is mainly with proc synergy where the new ability of choppas just works better for that, remove it and slayers comes back as king. In fact the current time is really flawed and if we compare st spec's the slayer still is better.
Chosen/KOTBs - Both are the same level of annoying, both are as good the difference is just that kotbs kills with reflect while running deftard snb while chosen runs 2h and can output some damage.
Shaman/Archmage - I can not agree with you about shamans being monstrosity, both are, especially AM with a spammable dot that removes 5% of your damage and reduces your crit chance by 5%, puddle removes init instead of other stuff that shaman does making it even better, not to talk about other stuff. although from the big perspective both are quite monstrosities for solo roam since they can do great dmg while still having good self heal capability.
I also see that you left mara/wl to keep your list order biased as much as possible when order has a WL monstrosity that can solo roam in AOE spec and still be a monster... 2/10 bait because i answered.