Tier 1-3 Scenarios are the most enjoyable content

[Mvl130]

The gear issue is minor, RR is still the OP part.
Opportunist IV it is +14% crit.
BiS gear is 16% crit.
Comparing Vanq with Sov straight up it is 1% crit that differs.
As soon as you hit Vanq level of gear you are more or less competitive gear wise. What you lack is 25 RR, those 25 RR lets you get 11% more parry or dodge/disrupt and e.g. 5% reduced CTBC from FS.

It's possible yes that the RR may be more responsible than gear for gap between rank 40 players

[Mvl130]

There's another argument I found in favor of midtier RvR Lakes, it is that since it would make it more enjoyable for veterans of the game to level up new alts, you'd have at the same time less players concentrated in T4 (less blob), and more available for midtier

[Scidadle]

It sounds to me like the bigger issue is the experience of being a fresh 40 character.

I am pretty much brand new to RoR/WAR and am leveling my first character right now, and after reading this thread, and other discussions on the forum, I can't say I'm very excited for rank 40/endgame.

Not sure I have enough knowledge to have a well thought out opinion/suggestions, but hopefully when I hit rank 40, I'm not just looking to reroll again.