So you just picked one part of his argument and ignored the rest?
The truth is rSH are squishier than most classes and all our defensive tools require you to be very proactive or are designed for escaping. We don't have the defensive stance buffs of SW, the armor buffs of engi and BW, no dot removal, no ranged knockdown. We're essentially a glass cannon without the cannon. Now you can either argue that we should or shouldn't have any of those things but if you think you're making some kind of point by taking one part of someone's argument and ridiculing it out of context, you're wrong.