Broadhead Arrow Suggestion.

[Arthem]

5 sec cooldown on a stackable dot xD

Interesting suggestion. So 10 seconds to get 3x stack if no dodge / cleanse / LOS. Yep.

SW has been butchered, you would have to revert changes to fix them atm.

Off the top of my head, don't make a stackable DoT aoe. ASW suffered due to making BHA the aoe dot rather than tinker with the useless Flame Arrow. There are options, however most of the complains are L2P issues.

[Onigokko0101]

Pandemonium/Frag Grenade/Gloom of Night etc all stack from multiple attackers just like BHA does.

BW used to have one too but Detonate was nerfed to **** early on live.

Pandemonium has only 1 stack and 5 sec cooldown tho. But whatever, we don't have to have a mirror everywhere. However, BHA should be definitely looked into if it has all three points 1)unlimited stacking from multiple sources 2) no defence checks after application 3) no cooldown.

Glean+Pande w/ Flamer (and Engi Equiv) does a bit more damage than BHA, and it leaves a tac slot free.

But yeah SW does bring up the sheer number of Order players with ranged AOE dot by a lot.

It absolutely does not. I dont know where this has perpetuated, but I have heard it multiple times in different places and its factually untrue. Pandemonium + Glean does about 300 less damage in simialr endgame gear to 3x BHA

[Onigokko0101]

double post

[Battlefield]

I have only 1 big question is why Squig Herder similar dot Yer Bleedin'! has 65 ft range
and 5 seconds cooldown and not stackable but BHAx3 100ft range and no cd?
It is not balance, i knew SW needed a buff but now SW in good hands is Overpowered class!
BHA does 5k+ damage for 15 sec and this is aoe ability with tactic, just omg.
I did not play in RoR from 2020 march i came back a week ago and sometimes i have thoughts what i do here if it happens but you searching a new players as i see....

[Caema]

You are investing 3 global cooldowns for a dot which can be cleansed by both dok and shaman. I am pretty sure with Yer Bleedin' + 2 global cooldowns you will deal equal maybe more damage overall with SH.(On single target ofc).
Not only Shadow warrior but every class is overpowered in good hands.(Especially Squig Herder)
Broadhead Arrow is joke in 6v6, it is okay in 24v24 and extremely powerful in fort defences. and that is because how forts work.

[Battlefield]

You are investing 3 global cooldowns for a dot which can be cleansed by both dok and shaman. I am pretty sure with Yer Bleedin' + 2 global cooldowns you will deal equal maybe more damage overall with SH.(On single target ofc).
Not only Shadow warrior but every class is overpowered in good hands.(Especially Squig Herder)
Broadhead Arrow is joke in 6v6, it is okay in 24v24 and extremely powerful in fort defences. and that is because how forts work.

All dots can be cleansed by healers this is stupid argument it's mechanic of this game !
Not all classes so good as SW now and and SH (range spec) worse than SW already.
Sorc can die fast from BHAx3.

[Caema]

Ofcourse all dots can be cleansed lol. but you dont spend 3 gdc on them

[Cultist]

When you see 3+ x BHAx3 you know you are pretty much done if you're a bit squishy like a Sorcerer, they just explode. Add Slayer's rampage to it (melts tanks) and more numbers and organization and the snowball effect is starting to get big... So either they do something about addressing these topics or Destro will be disbanded soon. I'm not playing Order despite of it all.

Oh, and having some Game Champs on Destro side would also help.

[Battlefield]

Ofcourse all dots can be cleansed lol. but you dont spend 3 gdc on them

BW may cleanse Yer bleedin' too.
What a problem make bhax1 but increase damagex2 and remove aoe
and reapet

why Squig Herder similar dot Yer Bleedin'! has 65 ft range and 5 seconds cooldown and not stackable but BHAx3 100ft range and no cd?

[madrocks]

The cleansing of BHA in a keep funnel situation is a myth.
We tested with: 2 shamans with cleanse, choppa and 2 shield tanks in the group.
Still BHA stacks constantly.

As other mentenioned in here, it's an issue when 10+ SW drop it in the funnel constantly.
I highly doubt it's a l2p issue.

It's the combination of all the dots in a funnel that make this things "overpowered". Also how the dot mechanic works now, with the refreshment, highly questionable.
Not to forget that destro now needs to slot a choppa, so a squishy class, to have CDR. Totally out of proportion.