Return of Reckoning

My suggestion is for developer to provide more context for balance type of discussion. I won't mention what I think of the design other than I don't agree with most of what's been proposed. If developer can provide a problem statement that would help everyone focus feedback on the area you seek feed...

Gunbad can be run faster with 3 dps and 1 (WELL GEARED TANK/conqueror+) on mid/right wing... it'll improve the speed of the run alot, especially you have aoe spec class like magus/sorc/choppa. You can ask dps to spec aoe for gunbad since respec is free, there are no dps races if I remember correctly...

It depends on what you want to do: Tank of all type already provide utility in form of guard/challenge - BO is the worst utility tank but are great at melee assist (they debuff armor) - Chosen are better because they are great just standing there with their aura, boring to play though (aura bot lite...

You want "protection of hoeth" first instead of phenoix wing (which is situational at best) That shield applys to your group so you "can" potentially save your team mate under focus and give you that edge to survive dots when you are walking back to your healer. It puts you in co...

Hardest class in general is SW. Hardest healer is AM. Hardest tank ... probably BG/IB as stated. What he said, notice order have two of the weakest classes SH >>>> SW (several melee build for aoe dmg or 6v6) Sha > AM (quite similar but better dps spec and doesn't have to deal with dest melee train,...

Depends what you want
Pve tanks: Defensive stat like block/parry/wound/armor/crit reduction
Pvp orvr: Block/armor/crit reduction/armor/toughness if you can get to it
2H tank: strength/parry/crit reduction/armor

[quote BO only has higher crit damage potential when using 2H + SYG. Otherwise SM in a competitive environment should always be out damaging BO due to the burst that comes from Ether Dance/Blurring Shock coupled with PE/EA tactics. [/quote] Except BO has first two equivalent tactics and the later tw...

If SM ether dance can be used for SnB build, then maybe? You can't buff one class and leaving the mirror behind. Borc still do more dmg than SM and already have better assist by default - armor debuff = great assist for all dest melee classes vs spirit debuff useful on dps AM (yay!?) - stab you good...

FO can be used with sword and shield, I've tried it before and it can be fun if there aren't too many melee and you are always the last to be targeted. I oppose buffing FO though since no one bother talking about opportunity cost of having a dps tank vs mdps... and people seem to forgot about taunt ...

Issue: WL class is defined both as melee dps class and a pet class. After the pet auto-attack fix, the pet damage potential for WL have been greatly lessen (for good reason, 100 dps weapon is too high). However, there is not much scaling for Guardian spec WL since most of the dmg comes from the pet....