Return of Reckoning

So I'm stuck between choosing the two. I'm an experienced tank from other mmo's so skill level doesn't really sway my opinion much but I'm just looking for which one is a better overall tank in pve and pvp.

First off much appreciation to the entire development team for reviving this game and the hours of work they've put into it, ya'll are awesome. I'm having an issue though in which I can create my character and they show up on the character screen and when I click PLAY it brings me to the loading ...