Return of Reckoning

Well Skavens would probably be possible because they did exist on Live (as a semi playable race).
The rest is wishful thinking as it indeed would require a full team and hundred of hours.
Everything that was added to the game in the past years came from unused existing assets (Dwarf/ork capital), so ...

Shield doK / WP (I play(ed) both extensively) was extremely enjoyable prior to Heal patch.
Nowadays, it's still more than decent in PvE, but lost half of its DPS if you want to heal efficiently. IT lacks big numbers so not very suitable to some LV fights (tree boss/Nkari), but otherwise still ...

You do realise BG punt is the most influential punt in the game and yes it isn’t mindless spam as a counter weight (requiring hate)


This makes me laugh every time someone uses this argument to pretend BG punt is still "ThE BeSt" punt in game. BG punt, at full charge, is slightly better than its ...

RvR in its current state is pretty pointless anyway, so at least Forts reseting fronts is a plus.
You can't balance RvR when people can swap side whenever they please, you can't make RvR interesting beyond the sole mass fighting enjoyment when taking fortress does no longer have a true meaning.

Very sceptical about the punt changes, they mean that BG currently has the worst possible form of single target punt since it still needs to ramp up with Hate. At least remove the hate requirement on the punt as you did for the stance requirement on SM.

Good thing that Guard once again stacks with ...

Warlord was already a wasted set on SM/Chosen since the WS > INI changes, but it's a bit of a shame that the only DP set designed for 2H users cannot be used because of a useless stat.

I didnt mention hardly concessions, because while it's a good mitigation boost, you may also struggle with aggro due to very low damages and it's vastly unnecessary if you have enough defensive stats of other sources.

I also think AoE threat management is pretty hard on BG these days, compared to ...

Just one more - is it important to have disrupt at PVE? or useless?

I would not spec for it in PvE just get Futile Strike (to 0% inc damage)/ max Parry / Block then maybe some straight STR RR (or Wounds if you are lacking).
There are very few spellcasters and most bosses who use spells won't ...

No issue with this fight once you know the mechanics.

The importants stats for PvE tanking are Armor, Wounds, Init and a little bit of Str for a more confortable threat generation. Toughness has been for a long time considered useless for PvE tanking because it only mitigates small amounts of damage which is pretty worthless against bosses, but some LV ...